Final Clinton Rally: High White Energy

by: Matt Stoller

Sat Jan 26, 2008 at 02:28


IMG_0376.JPG

I canvassed a bunch of black and mixed neighborhoods yesterday, and while I found a number of Hillary votes, this is meaningless because I don't know anything about the geography of the space or the lists that were cut.  What you see above was the crowd at the final Clinton rally, which was about 90% white and only about two thirds full in the convention center.  Hillary herself was in fine spirits, and I didn't see the same signs of organizational depression that I saw in Iowa.  They probably think they are going to get second, but feel well-positioned going forward. 

While white, it's not like the crowd were a bunch of bigots.  When Clinton discussed the magnitude of the election, in terms of having a son of the South, a black man, and a woman running for office, people cheered riotously.

Mostly I was struck once again by the discontinuity of Clinton's speech and the prattle in the news media.  She talked of solutions, of a laundry list of problems she really wanted to tackle, with very little about identity and very little about meta-politics (in contrast to Obama).  There's no new politics here, just hard work.  If there was an overall message, it was, if you loved the 1990s, you'll like my Presidency, though the mess we have to clean up is slightly bigger so we have more chores to do.  There were several retired higher echelon military in the audience, which she repeatedly singled out for praise.  Retired Generals and Admirals really do love her, and her mantra of working hard, governing with experience, and restoring American mystique to what it was resonates with people who see life through a competitive bureaucracy instead of the free-form floating cosmopolitan internet-ty organizer world of Obama.  That actually scares and angers them quite deeply.

There's one other point to note.  While the blogosphere and the media have parallel conversations about race, identity, electability, etc, it's not like these things don't matter to voters.  Voters are parroting these phrases, discussing who can win, who has more experience, who can bring change, who can attract independents and Republicans, etc.  When you talk to low information voters, they tell you these things that started with Brian Williams, only it often feels like they are a foreigner learning English.  It doesn't make sense but it has an impact.  So since this is considered an incredibly hard fought and dirty campaign in the press even though it's not, that's how voters will perceive it.

IMG_0389.JPGAnyway, those are my observations on the night before the primary.  I think Obama's going to take it by a wide margin, and Edwards and Clinton are going to split the white vote.  There is a slight chance that Edwards could collapse a la Nevada, but I think that's unlikely.  Obama's people want this one and have done the work. 

If you want to see more photos from the rally and/or pictures from a gay bar drag show in Charleston, why here you go.  Incidentally, there was a strange sort of power in being straight guy in a gay bar.  I'm not a bar type of person, but for some reason there were lots of attractive girls there who kept hitting on me.  Well they would do that until asking if I wanted to meet their friend 'Mike'.  It was like having a super power that misfired at the last second.

More soon.

Todd Beeton has a good rundown of the state of the polling and conventional wisdom in the race.

Matt Stoller :: Final Clinton Rally: High White Energy

Tags: , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Edwards (0.00 / 0)
I doubt, and hope, Edwards won't collapse like he did in Nevada.  He's put considerably more time and money there than he did in NV, where I think the campaign was hoping to just skate by.

From Edwards phone canvassers I know there are still many undecideds between Hillary and Edwards, with a slight break towards Edwards.  From what I gather Charlseton is Edwards's weakest area.


Nevada was completely different (0.00 / 0)
Nevada had a caucus, which had a viability threshhold in each precinct, which is why edwards only got ~5% of state delegates.  He probably would have recieved at least 10-15% of the vote if it had been a straight up primary.

SC is a primary, so every vote for the candidates counts.  If Edwards can beat Hillary, thats a big boost to Edwards (though I still don't see that helping him win the nom) and a bigger boost to Obama, imho.


[ Parent ]
Photos (0.00 / 0)

Matt: the pictures you uploaded to flickr do include the bar (and your canvassaging earlier in the day), but not from the rally as you had mentioned above?

I appreciate your "eyewitness" reporting and perspective!

Hans


The Race Baiting Clinton Campaign (0.00 / 0)
The Clinton strategy in South Carolina is part of the larger national plan, she's using South Carolina to racialize the entire race, and turned Barack Obama into the Black candidate, the plan is to create the appearance that Barack Obama as the candidate who represents African-Americans and no one else. And she's used her husband the former president, as well as political operative academics like Sean Wilentz to carry out this extremely distasteful and shameful mischaracterization. Simply put the Clintons are beneath contempt.

Bill Clinton, the former president, has now become the race baiter for the Clinton campaign, and his tactics are working, as white voters, who just weeks ago stood behind Barack Obama, have now fallen in behind Hillary Clinton who is being presented as the White candidate, who will represent the interests of White folks in the Democratic Party.  There is no excuse or explanation for these despicable reprehensible tactics, thay are direct appeal to the bassist racist tendencies in voters.  The idea of racial solidarity plays well in the South, but the Clinton campaign will try to spread this regressive deviance to the entire Democratic electorate across this nation.  The Clintons have shown their true colors, and their campaign is not about inclusion or unity, it's about division, deception and ignorance.


She can't exploit something that isn't already there (0.00 / 0)
Personally I think its great that people are talking about race that isn't all in coded references.

If she wins on race then I (and I suspect most Obama voters) would rather her get the nomination because if the democratic electorate is too hung up on race then certainly the general electorate will be.

The proper way to play it as you are doing is to make Hillary the "White southern" candidate the way she is trying to make him the black candidate.

I think it has a great chance of working.  A lot of the identity of the rest of the whites of the nation is wrapped up in stuff like "we are not like the racist bible belt south". 

Thus Obama losing the whites in SC could easily hurt hillary more than it hurts him if he plays it right.

After all SC isn't exactly going to go democratic so there are no fears of him losing the GE if he loses the whites in this state.


[ Parent ]
The irony (0.00 / 0)
is she is running on her husband's identity. I thought part of the exit poll from NH was interesting where they asked voters if they would vote for Bill Clinton first before the candidate they had just voted for. The Edwards and Obama numbers were small, those voters were dedicated to their candidate. But, huge numbers of Hillary voters said they would vote for Bill first.

Michael Bloomberg, prince of corporate welfare

All Cock, No Block (0.00 / 0)
My single straight buds LOVE going to gay bars with me.  Given the ratio of hot cool chicks to cool straight dudes, they usually have great luck!  ;)

Donate to Open Left









QUICK HITS

Friends of the Earth thanks the OpenLeft community for the ideas you generate and your contributions to the progressive movement.


blog advertising is good for you
blog advertising is good for you
SEARCH

   

Advanced Search