Clamping Down on Blog Dissent: More Evidence of State Blogger Problems

by: Matt Stoller

Mon May 19, 2008 at 15:27


I keep hearing more and more rumors that state parties simply chose the blogs that got credentials for the Democratic National Convention.  And the evidence seems to suggest that is the case.  I mentioned Michigan as one of the problem cases, so I'll walk you through why the selection seems odd.  The blog chosen to be credentialled was Blogging for Michigan, a progressive community blog.  It is a good blog.  But Michigan Liberal is far older and more established, with 737 RSS subscribers, a large number for a state-based blog.  Moreoever, ML has over 2200 technorati links, while Blogging for Michigan has just over 1000.

Why is this a big deal?  Financially speaking, conventions see big traffic boosts, and that means advertising revenue that Blogging for Michigan will get that Michigan Liberal will not.  Politically, Michigan Liberal won't get access to the floor delegation, and Blogging for Michigan will.  Of course, mistakes happen, but in this case, it's disturbing to see that the person granted the credentials, Cathleen Carrigan, is also an author on a sycophantic blog dedicated to praising Governor Jennifer Granholm and her policies, while Michigan Liberal has been quite outspoken about the Michigan Democratic Party's handling of the primary scheduling fiasco and its chair, the savvy and powerful Mark Brewer (who has something of a history with progressive bloggers).

The process for credentialling state bloggers has been problematic, with unclear standards and questionable motives for selecting bloggers.  Make no mistake, this is a financial and political decision - Michigan Liberal will lose out because of this choice, as will Blue Jersey.  And we have no idea why progressives and those critical of the party were turned down.  The Democratic National Convention has had subtle problems with bloggers for a long time now, with the lead spokesperson getting into it with the progressive tech giant blog BoingBoing.  The lack of thought going into the selection of progressive blogs is an easily correctable problem, and it's a problem the convention and the Democratic Party doesn't need.

Dissent is a good thing, and it would be a shame if independent progressive activists were penalized because they are willing to speak out about problems with the party.  That's how Republicans act.

UPDATE:  I'm told Carrigan actually works for the Governor.  I'll email her to find out.

Matt Stoller :: Clamping Down on Blog Dissent: More Evidence of State Blogger Problems

Tags: , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Not a fair criticism (4.00 / 5)
Calling the Governor Granholm blog "sycophantic" is missing the point perhaps. It's the official blog of the Governor, it's not going to be hard-hitting. Just saying.  

But is also shows ... (0.00 / 0)
that she was chosen because of her links to the Governor .. not because the blog was widely read or anything .. it's nepotism at its worst

[ Parent ]
no (0.00 / 0)
t's the official blog of the Governor, it's not going to be hard-hitting. Just saying.  

Um, then why is there a disclaimer on the blog saying that the site doesn't represent Granholm's opinions?  

You can't have it both ways, Laura.


[ Parent ]
The Maryland blog (0.00 / 0)
isn't a blog...it's a Baltimore City focused, progressive non-profit, personality-driven (Marc Steiner, formerly of WYPR) organization, producing radio-based news, with a website and one or two blog posts. Strange choice, considering that experience was required. (maybe no one else in MD applied?)

rgright (0.00 / 0)
It's a weird choice, but I'm not sure if anyone else applied.

[ Parent ]
Cathleen is a strong writer (4.00 / 1)
and BFM is an excellent blog.  But yes, they were not hard-hitting against Brewer and the MDP over the primary fiasco.

BFM deserves its credentials.  The solution is simply to add MichLib.  It sucks and gives Michigan twice the bloggers as other states, but come on, we're just really into fucking this entire primary thing up this year.

West Michigan Rising: Progressives On the West-End of the Third Coast


no (0.00 / 0)
ML deserves the credential, not BFM.  Just because we like someone doesn't mean they get access to limited space.  She doesn't deserve the slot.

[ Parent ]
Matt, it's not just that I like her (4.00 / 2)
It's that she's a hell of a writer on the second biggest progressive blog in Michigan.  Read some of her stuff: http://www.bloggingformichigan...

I wish there hadn't been a split in the MI blogosphere, I don't even have a strong understanding of what it was about.  I have some ideas and have heard some rumors, much of which are probably true and I'm actually sympathetic to all sides.  But BFM is just a damn good blog, yes, less trafficked, significantly, but I believe it has a strong case.

Now, if MichLib was axed by Brewer because Mark is a vindictive ass and not someone who was forced into the Fiasco by the Gov, then Howard Dean should overrule and get MichLib representation.

West Michigan Rising: Progressives On the West-End of the Third Coast


[ Parent ]
Without knowing the specifics (4.00 / 2)
Isn't having diversity a good thing in general?  It sounds like you are saying that the newer blog may have started or picked up traffic over a disagreement with the direction of the older blog.  This is inevitable.  It's a good sign that the progressive blogosphere gains this sort of critical mass where such splits are unavoidable.

Things You Don't Talk About in Polite Company: Religion, Politics, the Occasional Intersection of Both

[ Parent ]
ya (4.00 / 1)
So, I don't speak for Michigan Liberal and what I say absolutely doesn't reflect their views.

I don't think it is a coincidence that BFM has a decidedly pro-administration view, and got picked over ML which has been critical of the state party leadership.  That's consistent with what we've been hearing about in other states.

That being said, Cath is a great blogger and incredible photographer, and has been a mentor to those of us who started blogging about MI politics after her -- she deserves to go to the convention and this doesn't diminish that.


no (4.00 / 1)
If the criteria were clear, Michigan Liberal should have been picked.  If ML chose to give the credential to Cathy, fine.  But it is wholly inappropriate to give a credential to someone because they praise the Governor of a state.  That is straight up wrong.

[ Parent ]
i agree (4.00 / 1)
the process was not transparent / flawed, and if the MDP was involved in the decision it reflects very poorly upon them.

[ Parent ]
The Credential (4.00 / 7)
I have been speaking with the Michigan Democratic Party. They claim they are working with the DNC to get Michigan Liberal a credential for the convention. The MDP further claims they want us there, that they recognize the work we've done. Whether this will result in a credential for us, I don't know.

The MDP also believe WizardKitten (Cathleen) at BloggingforMichigan deserves the credential. You'll get no argument from me about that.

She's an excellent writer and she's going to take way better pictures than any of us at Michigan Liberal is capable of doing. (My digital camera is a puny little three-year-old Casio Exilim.)

I do not want a blog war, a gossip war, a feud, whatever. BFM and MichLib are on the same side of the political fence. We do go about things differently. But that's okay. We're lucky in our state that two great lefty community blogs have so much support.

Richard Hellinga
Assistant Editor

http://www.michiganliberal.com/


In defense of Cathleen (4.00 / 1)
As the ex-Governor Generalissimo of Michlib, I certainly share your sense of irritation at what has occured. However, I also have to take issue with your characterization of Cathleen. In reality, Cathleen has personally been blogging about Michigan politics since even before ML existed. And I think if you review the totality of her work - especially during the 2006 campaign, you'll see that she's quite a bit more than just a sycophant. When she's inspired, Cathleen truly is as good a writer as they come.

BTW, this is coming from someone whose relations with BFM haven't exactly been warm and fuzzy.


Donate to Open Left









QUICK HITS

Friends of the Earth thanks the OpenLeft community for the ideas you generate and your contributions to the progressive movement.


blog advertising is good for you
blog advertising is good for you
SEARCH

   

Advanced Search